I think most of us have seen images of athletes wearing a mask that is supposed to enhance performance.

The advertising for these systems is blunt: “Simulates extreme altitude training”. It even has accessories to change the airflow and in this way you can go from 3,000 feet (just under 1,000m) up to 18,000 feet (over 5,400m).

This statement seems to me to be a big hoax and very easy to understand. It is impossible to simulate a given altitude with a single filter. That can only be achieved with sophisticated machines that are capable of extracting oxygen from the air or even more complex systems such as chambers that reduce the amount (hypobaric). The former have high prices, although prices have decreased in the simplest models and there are some for less than 3,000 euros and the latter even more exorbitant prices. If it were as simple as doing it with a filter, these machines would not exist since it would be impossible to compete with the prices of these masks of less than 100 euros, and the rates of these services performed by specialists would be more economical.

Actually this mask system does not cause hypoxia, but hypercapnia (abnormal elevation of CO2 because it cannot be eliminated by the mask) and this in turn can cause hypoxemia which does cause a decrease in the partial pressure of arterial oxygen, but due to the increase in CO2 pressure.

That is to say, excess CO2 can cause hypoxemia in the masks, but totally uncontrolled, while in intermittent hypoxia machines a totally controlled hypoxemia is achieved without hypercapnia. Hypercapnia produces oxidative damage(Study), so it is preferable that it does not occur frequently.

The official website of these masks makes all these benefits safe:

– Increases lung capacity

– Increases the anaerobic threshold

– Increases oxygen efficiency

– Increases energy production

– Increases physical endurance

– Increases mental concentration

Although there are some scientific studies on the subject, none of them can speak of improvements in blood parameters (increase in red blood cells or hemoglobin mass), the main benefits of high-altitude training. This study, which may be the best reference, analyzes the effect of 6 weeks of training in cyclists using a group with a mask and another without it.

Saturation was controlled with pulse oximeter and despite being high intensity training and with the mask adjusted to high altitude saturations were quite similar, 94% with mask and 96% without mask. Something that in any exercise hypoxia training is considered as ineffective.

One of the conclusions of this study is that mask training is not an altitude simulator, but a training of the respiratory muscles.

In another more recent investigation carried out with cyclists during an incremental test, it was found that using the mask the performance was lower and was accompanied by a lower lactate production. Interestingly, muscular oxygenation remained identical to the control group and cerebral oxygenation increased(study).

In another study with similar characteristics, but this time working at 75% of the maximum power achieved in a previous test, the time to exhaustion was evaluated. When using the mask, the perception of effort increased, decreased by 37% and capillary oxygen saturation decreased (-2%). However, heart rate, lactate levels and muscle oxygenation were identical.

The scientific evidence so far is of improvements in lung volume, resistance to respiratory muscle fatigue and tolerance to high intensity exercise, improvements in recovery in repeated sprints and even a mental/brain effect in terms of improvements in the capacity for suffering and oxygenation of the cerebral cortex.

In other words, training masks have benefits, but they are nothing like those offered by altitude or intermittent hypoxia. Working with the masks has benefits more similar to a respiratory muscle training device (powerbreathe) in which you can work more precisely and where it has been studied that the improvements are greater than 50-70% of the maximum inspiratory pressure. With the traning mask it is possible to work at the same time as exercising, but according to research it seems a bad idea to work at high intensities due to the rapid exhaustion time and the difficulty in achieving high training stimuli (lactate, heart rate, muscular deoxygenation, etc.).

With a PowerBreathe you can work at rest and also during exercise and always in a controlled manner, so my recommendation is:

  • If you want to train in hypoxia get well informed to perform the proper protocol, there is more and more demand, cheaper machines, but few professionals who know the proper and individualized work.
  • If you need to improve your inspiratory muscles, measure yourself with an electronic PowerBreathe to know if your inspiratory pressure is at the right levels and if necessary train with it and the appropriate protocol to progress (the price is very similar to TrainingMask and the performance benefits are greater).