Normally when we buy a bike we look at the weight, aesthetics, components and some even at certain parts of the frame geometry. But very few pay attention to one of the most important aspects in the behavior and performance of the bike, the seat tube angle. It will affect the weight distribution of the body over the wheels, but also the pedaling action.

http://ivanreebok.blogspot.es/media/cache/resolve/media/files/00/402/723/2016/03/seat-tubevertical.jpg

A set-back seat tube places most of the weight on the rear wheel, allowing for greater stability and control of the bike.

However, a forward saddle angle puts more body weight on the handlebars, making the bike more nervous and unstable, but at the same time you enjoy better aerodynamics and the possibility of placing the handlebars in a lower position so as not to interfere with the hip-trunk angle.

Basically there are these differences in angles depending on the type of frame:

MTB Downhill with approximately 60-65º.

MTB Rally with 67-70º.

Road Bicycle with 71-73º.

Aero-road bike with 73-75º.

Bicycle time trial with 76-82º.

In terms of stability, there is no doubt that the set-back saddle, even lower than ideal (telescopic seatpost) will allow us to pass over areas of great difficulty.

But if we focus on pedaling efficiency the research says that the opposite is better. When comparing different seat tube angles (68º, 74º and 80º) it was found that the more forward position meant lower O2 consumption and heart rate, with the more backward angle having the worst efficiency(study).

Another study conducted with Olympic distance triathletes compared pedaling at an angle of 73 and 81 degrees on an indoor bike at 70% of VO2max. After 40km of cycling, it was found that cycling performance improved by 2%, but in the subsequent 10km race it even exceeded 7%, with the differences being more significant in the initial 5km. Wider strides and higher FC could be seen in the 81º position.

Even in very high intensity work, large differences can be seen. In this study, positions of 72 and 82 degrees were compared during a Wingate test. The main conclusion was that at 82 degrees power production can be better maintained and by electromyography that muscle activation for the same workload in the more advanced position was lower in all muscle groups (vastus lateralis, vastus medialis, biceps femoris and semimembranosus). In the case of the biceps femoris, the reduction in activation was 42%.

http://ivanreebok.blogspot.es/media/cache/resolve/media/files/00/402/723/2016/03/emg-05-25-g003.jpg

The latest research on this subject evaluated at two different submaximal intensities and with three angles, 70º, 75º and 80º, but with the novelty of analyzing with electromyography what occurred in different positions of the crank. It was possible to demonstrate that in the 80º position there was an optimization of the force applied to the pedal that reduced the demand on auxiliary muscles and improved pedaling economy(study).

But it seems that more is not always better, since in this study, reaching 90º, it was found that efficiency was lost again, with the optimum being 83º to minimize oxygen consumption.

Another very important aspect is to know the effect of the angle of the seat tube, the angle of the hip and the possibility to apply force. The ideal angle to apply force on the pedal is about 90º at the hip and if we move forward the position of the saddle, but do not lower the handlebar height, we make the angle very closed and lose efficiency as this study shows. So putting some bars on a road bike (relatively high handlebars) with a delayed saddle angle can improve aerodynamics, but worsen the energy cost by excessively closing the hip angle.

Summary:

  • Before buying your next bike consider this parameter, as you have found it can change the bike’s response and pedaling efficiency.
  • If you feel insecure on your bike (especially MTB), it may be advisable to use a bike that has the saddle angle set further back or even set the saddle back so that the bike will be more stable.
  • If you want to improve pedaling efficiency, move the saddle forward for better results and less muscle activation.
  • Within the saddle angle that is somewhat fixed in a frame, we have the option in some cases to use reversible seatposts to have different angles (usually to get more forward positions).
  • The possibility of moving the saddle rails allows us some degree of difference (normally we can have a play of about 4-5º). If you compete in cycling you have to take into account the UCI regulations, but now it has become a little more flexible and allows you to move the position forward as long as the saddle does not exceed the vertical of the bottom bracket axle.
  • Any changes in the biomechanics of the bicycle, especially if they are going to be abrupt, should be supervised by a professional to advise the best guidelines to follow and find the best option between efficiency, stability and comfort.